Make your own free website on Tripod.com

Multicultural Literature for Youth

Author Study - Taylor (6)
Home | Int. Lit #1 | Int. Lit # 2 | Int. Lit #3 | African Am. Lit #1 | African Am. Lit # 2 | African Am. Lit #3 | Latino Lit #1 | Latino Lit # 2 | Latino Lit #3 | Native Am. Lit #1 | Native Am. Lit #2 | Native Am. Lit #3 | Asian Pac. Am. Lit #1 | Asian Pac. Am. Lit #2 | Asian Pac. Am. Lit #3 | Inclusive Lit # 1 | Inclusive Lit # 2 | Inclusive Lit # 3 | Author Study: Taylor (1) | Author Study: Taylor (2) | Author Study: Taylor (3) | Author Study: Taylor (4) | Author Study: Taylor (5) | Author Study - Taylor (6)

 

Taylor - Comparison of Roll My Thunder, Hear My Cry and The Well

In both books, one main theme is the importance of family. The extended family in both stories is warm and close-knit. Family members will do anything to help each other in times of need.  In Roll of Thunder, Hammer, Papa’s brother, sells his fancy car to help the family pay the land mortgage that has been called early. The four siblings are protective of each other, and Cassie insists on accompanying Stacey when he takes the injured T.J. home. In The Well, a prequel to Roll of Thunder, Hammer physically defends his younger brother, David, after Charlie has hurt David. When Hammer faces trouble for beating up Charlie, a White boy, Mama crafts a plan to keep Hammer out of harm's way.

 

A second main theme in both books is the importance of land. Referring to Roll of Thunder, Crowe writes, “For him (David Logan), the Logans and the land are symbiotic, each depending and prospering because of the other. And although the Logans must scrimp and sacrifice to keep their land, (land ownership)…allows them the luxury denied their neighbors: to remain independent and together” (Crowe, 104). In Roll of Thunder, David goes to Louisiana to lay track, earning money that insures he can pay his mortgage and taxes. When Cassie asks her father why the land is so important, David answers, “Look out there, Cassie girl. All that belongs to you. You ain’t never had to live on nobody’s place but your own, and long as I live and the family survives, you’ll never have to. That’s important” (7).  Land is equally important in The Well. David and Hammer’s father and older brothers are “lumbering” away from home “to get money for taxes and for some of the things Papa and Mama wanted our family to have, including more land” (21). When David and Hammer are about to be whipped in front of Charlie and his father,  Hammer says he is not going but changes his mind because he does not want to “jeopardize the family and the land” (Crowe, 113).

 

Both books depict many incidences of racism. Many of these are described in the book reviews on previous pages.  In Roll of Thunder, one always feels the tension of racism in the background. The book begins and ends with two big racist events. Early on, a Black family’s house is burned by night riders, and at least one person dies. Near the end, a mob decides T.J. is guilty without a trial and nearly lynches him. In The Well, Hammer and David are severely punished because Hammer hits a White boy who hurts David first. Again, readers feel racial tension throughout the story.

 

In addition, both books are rich with cultural markers. Many of these have been discussed in the Author Study book reviews. The markers include a close-knit extended family, a willingness to help neighbors in need, a variety of foods such as sweet-potato pie, and a Black southern dialect.

 

There also are some differences between the two works. The Well is short and more of a novella, and it is not divided into chapters. Roll of Thunder is a 276-page novel that is divided into twelve chapters; the characters and themes are better developed in the longer work. The Well centers around one incident that is resolved at the end. Roll of Thunder centers around several incidents, and readers leave the book with out being sure of the outcome.  Finally, The Well has a plot that moves quickly, and it is a fast-paced read. Roll of Thunder can be slow at times, particularly early on, although this reviewer did not get bored. Later on, Roll of Thunder picks up steam, and the reader leaves wanting more. Luckily, the reader can look forward to Taylor’s other sequels and prequels about the Logan family.

 

Reference:

 

Crowe, Chris. 1999. Presenting Mildred D. Taylor. New York: Twayne Publishers. ISBN: 0-8057-1687-4.

 

 

Mildred Taylor Quote:
 
"When  my father and other storytellers shared the pain of their lives and the lives of others with me, I was outraged that one person would treat another person with such inhhumanity and disrespect, and I grew from that outrage, determined to pass the stories on" (Foreward from Roll of Thunder, 25th anniversay edition, 2001).